212 N Story Street, Appleton, WI 54914 $269,900

212 N Story Street, Appleton BD: 5 BA: 2/0 $269,900 Active-Without Bump

  • Single Family Home
  • Status: Active-Without Bump
  • Mailing City: APPLETON
  • County: Outagamie
  • 5 Bedrooms
  • 2 Full Bathrooms
  • Est. Square Footage: 2,295
  • Parking: 0.0
  • Est. Acreage: 0.24
  • School Dist: Appleton Area
  • Property Taxes: $4,832
  • Property Tax Year: 2024
  • MLS#: 50307287
  • Listing Company: Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
  • Price/SqFt: $117
  • Zip Code: 54914

212 N Story Street, Appleton, WI 54914 - Victorian 5 bedroom 2 bathroom 2 story is loaded with character and old world charm from the 1800s and is situated on an oversized 210' deep lot walking distance from downtown Appleton Music festivals and Farmers market. Special features include: Ornate woodwork, Maple floors with Walnut & Cherry listelo work, Phoenician plaster and floor to ceiling original cabinetry in the island kitchen. The huge backyard offers a Pergola patio with a custom stone oven and raised planting beds. Currently a single family home but offers 2 flat potential or Mother in law suite as well. Showings start 5/2/25. Allow 48 hours for acceptance of any offer. Sellers ideal closing date is 6/9/25 Exterior Siding is wood and slate

Main

  • Living/Great Rm: 13x13
  • Kitchen: 11x11
  • Formal Dining Rm: 12x14
  • BR 2: 9x9
  • BR 3: 9x11

Upper

  • Family Rm: 13x15
  • Primary BR: 14x9
  • BR 4: 9x9
  • BR 5: 9x10
  • Bonus Room: 11x11

Lower

  • Rec Room: 9x16
  • Game Room: 7x12
Additional Features
  • Finished, Full, Partial Fin. Non-contig
  • Construction Type: E
  • Victorian
  • Waterfront/Access: N
Property History
MLS Number New Status Previous Status Activity Date New List Price Previous List Price Sold Price DOM
50307287 Active-Without Bump Active May 5 2025 9:35PM 23
50307287 Active May 1 2025 12:19PM $269,900 23
50243934 Sold Pending Sep 3 2021 12:00AM $230,000 54
50243934 Pending Active-Without Bump Sep 9 2021 1:08AM 54
50243934 Active-Without Bump Active Jul 21 2021 9:12AM 54
50243934 Active Jul 12 2021 3:09PM $199,900 54

    Estimated Monthly Payment

    $3,287 per month
    Calculate Payment

    Make An Appointment

    Contact Shorewest

    1.800.434.7350

    Schedule a Showing

    Get More Info

    Receive more detailed information on this property

    Ask a Question

    The information which is contained on pages with property data is obtained from a number of different sources and which has not been independently verified or confirmed by the various real estate brokers and agents who have been and are involved in this transaction. If any particular measurement or data element is important or material to buyer, Buyer assumes all responsibility and liability to research, verify and confirm said data element and measurement. Shorewest Realtors is not making any warranties or representations concerning any of these properties. Shorewest Realtors shall not be held responsible for any discrepancy and will not be liable for any damages of any kind arising from the use of this site.
    REALTOR *MLS* Equal Housing Opportunity

    Rates and fees are subject to adjustments based on your credit score and the loan-to-value ratio. Rates and fees are also subject to change without notice. Other rates and loan programs are available.
    All applications are subject to current underwriting guidelines and credit approval. EHL NMLS#280412

    • Heritage Title Services, Inc.
    • The Realty Alliance
    • Wisconsin Mortgage Corporation
    • Leading Real Estate Companies of the World
    • Luxury Portfolio International
    • Shorewest Financial Associates LLC
    • HSA Home Warranty - Because Service Matters